Saw it this weekend. Second best broadway show I have ever seen (#1 was Thoroughly Modern Millie in previews). Only flaw is that it is a smaller theater with a smaller stage -- therefore a smaller chorus for dance numbers. The chorus is 8-10 people which is what you normally see in touring productions. I like a good 14-16 on the Great White Way.
The New York Times review is a travesty. This is a dynamite show. Good tickets available through discount coupons (broadwaybox.com). Great seats available at full price via Amex Gold Card events.